Three justices of the seven-member North Carolina Supreme Court and five judges of the 15-member North Carolina Court of Appeals were elected by North Carolina voters on November 3, 2020, concurrently with other state elections. Terms for seats on each court are eight years. These elections were conducted on a partisan basis.
Incumbent Court of Appeals Judges Linda McGee and Wanda Bryant (both Democrats) did not reopen their campaign accounts with the State Board of Elections, indicating they would not run for re-election, and they did not file for re-election by the time filing closed on Dec. 20, 2019.
Only one candidate from each party filed for each seat, meaning that no party primary elections would be necessary.
In the general election, Republican candidates won all of the races. The results of the Chief Justice race were only confirmed after a lengthy recount process, because of the narrow margin.
Supreme Court Chief Justice
Chief Justice Mark Martin, a Republican, announced his resignation in 2019, triggering an election for his seat in 2020. Governor Roy Cooper appointed Associate Justice Cheri Beasley, a Democrat, to become Chief Justice through 2020.
Beasley requested a recount on Nov. 17, 2020.ABC 11/WTVD After the recount found the margin between the candidates to be 401 votes, Beasley called for a second recount in a sampling of precincts statewide, as allowed by law.Cheri Beasley on Twitter Beasley then conceded the election to Newby on Dec. 12.ABC11/WTVD: Paul Newby wins North Carolina Supreme Court race as incumbent Cheri Beasley concedes
Candidates Cheri Beasley (Democratic), incumbent Chief Justice Paul Martin Newby (Republican), incumbent Associate Justice
Polling Poll source Date(s)administered Samplesize Marginof error CheriBeasley (D) PaulNewby (R) UndecidedCardinal Point Analytics (R)Cardinal Point Analytics (R)October 27–28, 2020750 (LV)± 3.6%45%44%11%Meeting Street Insights (R)Meeting Street Insights (R) October 24–27, 2020600 (LV)± 4%49%44%4%Harper Polling/Civitas (R) October 22–25, 2020 504 (LV) ± 4.4%49% 40% 11%Harper Polling/Civitas (R)Harper Polling/Civitas (R) September 17–20, 2020 612 (LV)± 3.96%44%38%18%
with Generic Democrat and Generic Republican Poll source Date(s)administered Samplesize Marginof error GenericDemocrat GenericRepublican Other/UndecidedHarper Polling/Civitas (R) September 17–20, 2020 612 (LV)± 3.96%43%43%14%Harper Polling/Civitas (R)Harper Polling/Civitas (R)August 6–10, 2020600 (LV)± 4%38%40% ≈22%-23%Harper Polling/Civitas (R)Harper Polling/Civitas (R) April 5–7, 2020 500 (LV) ± 4.4%39% 36% 25%Harper Polling/Civitas (R)Harper Polling/Civitas (R) Released March 17, 2019 – –36%34%30%
Results
Seat 2
The seat held by Associate Justice Paul Martin Newby was up for election in 2020. Newby announced that he would run for Chief Justice instead, leaving his Associate Justice seat open.
Candidates Phil Berger Jr. (Republican), incumbent judge of the North Carolina Court of Appeals Lucy Inman (Democratic), incumbent judge of the North Carolina Court of Appeals
Polling Poll source Date(s)administered Samplesize Marginof error PhilBerger Jr. (R) LucyInman (D) UndecidedMeeting Street Insights (R)October 24–27, 2020600 (LV)± 4%43%47%7%
Results
Seat 4
Beasley's elevation to the position of Chief Justice made her Associate Justice seat vacant, which also triggered a 2020 election. Governor Cooper appointed Court of Appeals Judge Mark A. Davis to fill the vacancy as an associate justice.
Candidates Tamara P. Barringer (Republican), former state senator (2012–2019) Mark A. Davis (Democratic), incumbent Associate Justice
Polling Poll source Date(s)administered Samplesize Marginof error Mark A.Davis (D) Tamara P.Barringer (R) UndecidedMeeting Street Insights (R)October 24–27, 2020600 (LV)± 4%50%42%6%
Results
Court of Appeals Seat 4 Candidates Declared Tricia Shields (Democrat), attorney and Campbell University Law School instructor April C. Wood (Republican), North Carolina District Court Judge
Results
Seat 5 Candidates Declared Lora Christine Cubbage (Democrat), North Carolina Superior Court Judge Fred Gore (Republican), North Carolina District Court Judge
Results
Seat 6 Candidates Declared Chris Dillon (Republican), incumbent Court of Appeals Judge Gray Styers (Democrat), attorneyNews & Observer
Results
Seat 7 Judge Reuben Young, a Democrat, was appointed by Gov. Roy Cooper to fill a vacancy, through the end of 2020, and was eligible to run for a full term. Candidates Declared Jeff Carpenter (Republican), North Carolina Superior Court Judge Reuben Young (Democrat), incumbent Court of Appeals JudgeState Board of Elections: State candidate list by county
Results
Seat 13 Judge Christopher Brook, a Democrat, was appointed by Gov. Roy Cooper to fill a vacancy, through the end of 2020, and was eligible to run for a full term. Candidates Declared Christopher Brook (Democrat), incumbent Court of Appeals Judge. Jefferson G. Griffin (Republican), North Carolina District Court Judge
Results
Notes
References